| Platinum | LA Pizzeria Metro |
| Gold | Mazzella's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Cafe Riviera |
| Bronze | Pat's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Pizzeria Mariana |
| Top Pick | Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Cafe Sitaly |
| Top Pick | Cafe Verdi |
| Top Pick | Charlie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gianni's Pizza |