| Platinum | Vincente's Restaurant |
| Gold | Casapulla's Elsmere Steak Shop |
| Silver | El Diablo Burritos |
| Bronze | The Chancery Market |
| Top Pick | Big Fish Grill On The Riverfront |
| Top Pick | Chelsea Tavern |
| Top Pick | Harry's Savoy Grill |
| Top Pick | Harry's Seafood Grill |
| Top Pick | LA Pizzeria Metro |
| Top Pick | Mazzella's Italian Restaurant |