| Platinum | Vincente's Restaurant |
| Gold | Mrs. Robino's Restaurant |
| Silver | Ristorante Attilio |
| Bronze | Cafe Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Al Forno |
| Top Pick | LA Pizzeria Metro |
| Top Pick | Luigi Vitrone's Pastabilities |
| Top Pick | Piccolina Toscana |
| Top Pick | Ristorante Attilio |
| Top Pick | Tony and Dominick's Pizza |