| Platinum | Sweet Somethings |
| Gold | Dino's Ice Cream & Water Ice Store |
| Silver | Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard |
| Bronze | Woodside Farm Creamery |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Carvel Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Fusco's Water Ice |
| Top Pick | Ice Cream Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Serpe & Sons Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sweet Nel's |